Resident and Professional Voices

Local Opinion

Local residents did not know about the local pictograph sites, although they were against graffiti. In their opinions, graffiti makes the neighborhood unattractive and conducive to increase in crime. It also negatively affects the property values within the neighborhood. In regards to the Native American community the residents feel that graffiti is disrespectful towards them. The residents also believe that if the neighborhood had better programs in terms of education, vandalism would be greatly reduced.

Native American & Archaeological Perspective

Desireé Reneé Martinez, a Tongva archaeologist, spoke to us about indigenous archaeology and the relationship between tribes and archaeologists in regards to ritual sites and burial grounds. As both a Native American and an archaeologist, we asked how she reconciles the archeological need for knowledge with the Native American need for secrecy, giving our project as an example. She replied that it is a very difficult issue, but that ultimately the desire for secrecy must be respected. She also said that for certain sites (she specifically mentioned puberty sites), outside knowledge of the site takes power away from the Native American community. She expressed the barrier between archaeologists and Native Americans in the form of questions: archaeologists ask, "Who are you to withhold this information?" and Native Americans ask, "Who are you to ask for this information?" and the disagreement only perpetuates misunderstanding. One other interesting thing she said was that she will not show pictographs when she teaches. She said that she does not know what the images were drawn for and what powers they might have, and that she doesn't want to be responsible for bringing harm to someone in her class by showing them images that could affect them in some way.

Conservator Claire Dean with San Luis Rey Official
Last update: April 28, 2008 by Lucy Harrington
The University of Southern California does not screen or control the content on this website and thus does not guarantee the accuracy, integrity, or quality of such content. All content on this website is provided by and is the sole responsibility of the person from which such content originated, and such content does not necessarily reflect the opinions of the University administration or the Board of Trustees